Moderator: Moderator Pack
reader4 wrote:Curious to know how you prep the snipe. I found a soggy farm field this year that had many snipe in the grasses near cattail ponds. Took one out of curiosity. So little meat in there... decided it wasn't worth the effort of taking more.
Incidentally, my young pup didn't pick up on the snipe either. I attributed it to lack of exposure / experience, but I also wondered how much the scent of the rotting marsh masks the birds? They get dug in pretty deep there...
AverageGuy wrote:reader4 wrote:Curious to know how you prep the snipe. I found a soggy farm field this year that had many snipe in the grasses near cattail ponds. Took one out of curiosity. So little meat in there... decided it wasn't worth the effort of taking more.
Incidentally, my young pup didn't pick up on the snipe either. I attributed it to lack of exposure / experience, but I also wondered how much the scent of the rotting marsh masks the birds? They get dug in pretty deep there...
I got into a bunch of snipe in the same type of habitat back in September. Wet field butting up to a large cattail marsh. Snipe everywhere. Neither my pup or my adult dog would point them. The adult dog acted like they were a complete non-target species. I took 10 species of upland birds over him last season including woodcock so it's not like he won't point a bird.
I have also had other dogs which naturally pointed pigeons, quail, pheasants, grouse that would not point a woodcock or a snipe.
They obviously smell different is my conclusion.
Willie T wrote:AverageGuy wrote:reader4 wrote:Curious to know how you prep the snipe. I found a soggy farm field this year that had many snipe in the grasses near cattail ponds. Took one out of curiosity. So little meat in there... decided it wasn't worth the effort of taking more.
Incidentally, my young pup didn't pick up on the snipe either. I attributed it to lack of exposure / experience, but I also wondered how much the scent of the rotting marsh masks the birds? They get dug in pretty deep there...
I got into a bunch of snipe in the same type of habitat back in September. Wet field butting up to a large cattail marsh. Snipe everywhere. Neither my pup or my adult dog would point them. The adult dog acted like they were a complete non-target species. I took 10 species of upland birds over him last season including woodcock so it's not like he won't point a bird.
I have also had other dogs which naturally pointed pigeons, quail, pheasants, grouse that would not point a woodcock or a snipe.
They obviously smell different is my conclusion.
Personally I think all the bird species must smell differently. I also believe a good dog learns to handle the different birds differently based on scent recognition combined with the cover they are in when given enough opportunity.
Willie.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests